"Novel Review Process: Canine Critique of Your Next Paper?"

In a whimsical turn of events, an eight-month-old Labrador retriever named Indiana Grimes-Carthy Bones, affectionately known as Indy, has found himself listed as a reviewer for a veterinary journal. The mastermind behind this unexpected addition to academic circles is none other than scientist and author David Robert Grimes. Grimes recounts his playful prank that led to Indy's inclusion as a reviewer, shedding light on the darker side of scientific publishing.

Grimes, bombarded with emails from predatory publishers, decided to have some fun and replied to one of them, suggesting Indy as a potential reviewer. To his surprise, the journal accepted the offer without questioning Indy's credentials, showcasing the alarming lack of scrutiny in the publishing process. While the incident brought a moment of levity, Grimes emphasizes the underlying issue of predatory publishing and its detrimental impact on the scientific community.

The story of Indy, the dog reviewer, serves as a poignant reminder of the pressing need to address the flaws in the academic publishing system. Grimes advocates for increased scrutiny and accountability, urging scientists to confront the pervasive issue of fraudulent practices and substandard research. He highlights the culture of hyperpublishing and the lack of repercussions for unethical behavior, emphasizing the urgent need for reform within the scientific community.

As Grimes reflects on the broader implications of his lighthearted experiment, he calls upon scientists to wake up to the challenges facing their field and take proactive steps towards ensuring the integrity of research. While the tale of Indy may evoke a chuckle, it also serves as a poignant commentary on the deeper issues plaguing scientific publishing.

Amidst the lighthearted anecdote of a dog turned reviewer, Grimes delivers a sobering message about the state of academic publishing and the imperative for change. Through his playful prank, he shines a light on the shadows of predatory practices and the urgent need for a reevaluation of scientific integrity.

As the scientific community grapples with these challenges, the story of Indy stands as a symbol of the resilience and adaptability required to navigate the ever-evolving landscape of academic research.

Source: https://www.science.org/content/article/scienceadviser-will-your-next-paper-be-reviewed-dog